The Best Crib Mattress Toppers for Your Baby’s Bed

We only pick products we trust, based on independent research by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may receive a commission to create new content for you.

​One of the challenges to your toddler’s happy sleep is the comfort of his or her bed. Adding a high-quality crib mattress topper can significantly improve the coziness of your toddler’s bed.

You already bought a good, firm and safe crib mattress for your newborn baby. Now your baby has grown a little, is more able to move, and you have a new challenge: How to make your little one sleep longer and in their own bed? Here, the comfort factor is essential.

Apart from safety and firmness, it’s essential to create a cozy and slightly softer crib environment that promotes peaceful and longer sleep for your baby.

If you don’t want to change your mattress, because it is still very suitable, the simple and effective solution is to buy a topper for the crib mattress.

When selecting a crib mattress topper, you need to consider a few things. These include the size, thickness, materials, and most importantly, softness. Your toddler would be sleeping on top of this pad, so it needs to be extra soft.

If you’re in search of a crib mattress topper, we have thoroughly reviewed three top-notch options for you.

Reviews of the Best Crib Toppers

1. Little One’s Pad Pack N Play Crib Mattress Cover

Check Price on Amazon
  • Highly comfortable
  • No crinkling sound
  • Great value for money
  • Easy to clean
  • Maybe too tight for using in bassinets with a foldable mattress

This crib pad cover from Little One’s Pad is designed to fit a variety of crib mattresses. It is a high-quality topper made from thin threads to last long. This top-notch mattress cover offers great comfort and coziness for the toddler.

  • Size and Fit

It can virtually fit all crib sizes as the dimensions are 27 x 39 x 5 inches. This means that it can easily fit mattresses with a thickness of up to five inches. If you have a Graco Pack N Play, a foldable mattress, Dream on Me mattress, Nuna Sena, PnP, or Evenflo, this cover should be compatible.

  • Properties

The cover is absorbent and waterproof. It will not let the mattress get damp. Also, the multiple layers of the cover are bacteria-resistant and odorless.

The fabric is hypoallergenic, ensuring it would not trigger any form of allergies. Most importantly, it is machine washable, so cleaning it should be a breeze.

  • Padding

The Little One’s Pad Mattress Cover has a uniform and soft padding. It has a perfect balance between a cover and a pad which allows you to use it as both.

There is not too much padding, so the cover is not too thick. That is because too much padding can interrupt with spine formation of the baby. Additionally, the topper is quilted to provide better support.

Feel free to read our comprehensive guide about the best mattresses for pack ‘n plays.

2. Milliard Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress Topper

Check Price on Amazon
  • Fits virtually any crib mattress
  • Easy to wash
  • High-quality and toxin-free materials
  • Increases comfort
  • Waterproof
  • Has an odor that does not come off easily

This crib mattress topper or cover is designed to provide the utmost comfort for the toddler. It contours to the body of the child, giving it all the support during sleep time when the body grows the most.

It is also travel-friendly as you can roll it up easily. In terms of stiffness, it is qualified as medium-firm with a 2.5-pound density. It comes from Milliard, which is a well-known brand for its quality and a wide range of baby products. The USA-based is also recognized for its high-end products all over the world.

  • Size and Fit

This mattress topper from Milliard measures 52 inches in length and 28 inches in width. It comes in one standard size that can easily fit most crib mattresses. There is a portable crib topper version of the same product that measures 38 x 24 inches.

  • Properties

It has a removable zippered cover that is waterproof. The pad and the cover are machine washable and dryable. The cover is also hypoallergenic which ensures protection from germs, bacteria, dust mites, and other allergens.

This topper has an open cell structure that allows for air ventilation. As a result, the pad does not get hot, and the baby does not sweat while sleeping.

  • Padding

This product is filled with soft polyester fiberfill which offers comfort with high density. That will ensure that the topper does not lose shape or get uneven.

3. Margaux and May Bamboo Crib Mattress Protector Pad

Check Price on Amazon
  • Extremely soft
  • Universal fit
  • Waterproof cover
  • Good value for money
  • No padding

If softness is your number one consideration, the Margaux and May Bamboo Crib Mattress Protector Pad is the answer. The inside padding combined with the quilted terry top cover makes for a very smooth crib mattress topper. It will put your baby to sleep in minutes.

  • Size and Fit

This mattress top comes in two sizes. The bigger one measures 52 x 28 inches whereas the smaller one measures 39 x 27 inches.

The former has a skirt of nine inches while the latter has a skirt of five inches. These dimensions allow this protector pad to be compatible with most crib mattresses. The fabric is also elasticized; thus, it fits the mattress tightly.

  • Properties

This product is highly absorbent and waterproof. It is also noise-free as the plastic backing does not make any crinkling sound. Additionally, the materials used in this cover are all breathable which aids ventilation.

The waterproof film (eco-friendly polyurethane) on the cover helps protect the topper and mattress. However, it should not be used at high-temperature levels as the waterproof film might be damaged.

  • Padding

This pad does not contain padding because it acts as a protector pad for the mattress. That said, it can make any stiff mattress more comfortable. Hence, if you need something extra thick and padded, this topper may not work for your purpose.

The Best Choice

All of the above products are actually quite soft and have protective features, but if you already have a soft crib mattress, you may want to go for the Margaux and May Bamboo Crib Mattress Protector Pad. It will protect the mattress and provide the comfort your toddler needs.

That being said, amongst the three, the best of the best crib mattress topper would be the Milliard Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress Topper. It is durable, soft, and serves the purpose of having a pad or cover well.

First, it can fit most mattresses. Second, it is made from quality materials that offer sustainability, reliability, and comfort. It is also waterproof and breathable.

The mattress will stay protected while you can wash the pad in the washing machine easily. Therefore, you get your money’s worth, and your baby gets a good night’s sleep every time.